Showing posts with label Ukraine. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Ukraine. Show all posts

Wednesday, 20 April 2022

The War In Ukraine: The Infantry Is Obsolete

 
 
 
But will a video of a Ukrainian infantry section attacking Russian infantrymen,who apparently drove a convoy of soft skinned civilian vehicles to within yards of the enemy without posting any security,convince transformationalists that the infantry is obsolete?
 

Sunday, 17 April 2022

The War In Ukraine: General Sir Richard Barrons

 
General Sir Richard Lawson Barrons KCB CBE the then Commander of Joint Forces Command on the 23rd of April 2013
 
 
One could be forgiven for thinking that the former Commander Joint Forces Command,General Sir Richard Barrons,had never been a British Army officer as his article in today's Sunday Times newspaper about the current unpleasantness in Ukraine not only lacks the acronyms and buzzwords which make so many sound like teenage management trainees but also appears to have been written by a man who understands the bloody business of land warfare,however,this otherwise very sensible piece must be challenged on the claim that tanks need to be "made lighter".
 
A Royal Scots Dragoon Guards Challenger 2 Main Battle Tank prepares to fire its main gun during a training exercise near Basra in Iraq on the 17th of November 2008
 
 
Protection against modern infantry weapons weighs hundreds of pounds per square foot,protection against tank fire is even heavier,and a modern armoured vehicle is further burdened by the increasing volume and weight demands of weapons,sensors,communications,countermeasures,battle management systems and their associated power and cooling requirements,a problem which would be exacerbated by the adoption of electric propulsion.
 
A T72 tank destroyed during the Russian invasion of Ukraine near Mariupol on the 7th of March 2022
 
 
Unless the laws of physics change,the trend for ever bigger and heavier tanks is likely to continue and heavy losses of medium tanks in Kuwait,Chechnya,Iraq and Ukraine demonstrate the consequences of ignoring the reality of armoured vehicle design.
 

Friday, 15 April 2022

The Three Lemons

 
A Pinzgauer Vector the highest priority of General Sir Richard Dannatt Commander in Chief Land Command on Salisbury Plain during the Vehicle Study Day on the 13th of September 2006
 
 
For centuries historians have struggled to explain the United Kingdom's frequent military defeats,but it was not until the advent of internet forums that the military illiteracy behind the deaths of hundreds of thousands of British soldiers became well documented,however,senior officers have long recorded their ignorance for posterity through the medium of defence procurement and herein we shall discuss several current projects.
 
An Ajax armoured fighting vehicle during cold weather system trials at Tame Ranges in Sweden between February and March 2019
 
 
An equivalent to and contemporary of the British Warrior Infantry Fighting Vehicle,A.S.CO.D. (Austrian Spanish COoperative Development) was developed by Austria and Spain,but despite needing a much larger number of vehicles,the British Army chose the improved A.S.CO.D. 2,rather than an all new design or a Warrior variant,as the basis of it's transformational Future Rapid Effects System which later became Ajax,an armoured reconnaissance vehicle which has neither the protection to withstand hits from weapons such as the 9M133M Kornet-M missile and 2A46 tank gun nor the fire power to suppress them,and which therefore must conduct reconnaissance by stealth,a task which requires neither medium armour nor a medium cannon,however,as Ajax currently does not work it may never enter service,which would be most fortunate.
 
A 99 Squadron Globemaster unloads new British Army Apache helicopters from Kansas City in the United States at Royal Air Force Brize Norton on the 24th of November 2020
 
 
Designed almost half a century ago,the Apache attack helicopter,as one of the few aircraft capable of delivering large numbers of precision weapons at night,had it's "happy time" attacking Iraqi forces during the liberation of Kuwait in Nineteen Ninety-one,a dozen years after that,during the invasion of Iraq,a force similar in size to the British Army's entire front line attack helicopter fleet was shot to pieces,in half an hour,by the poorly trained and equipped Medina Division over Karbala and in the Afghan war and Iraq wars combined more Apaches were lost than any other manned aircraft type,nevertheless,British Army officers decided that in an era of precision guided weapons a helicopter,with a large signature,which flies at slow speed and low altitude in close proximity to,and direct line of sight of,the enemy was the future of air warfare,before ordering another fifty,which may still be in service for the aircraft's eightieth birthday.
 
A Boxer Combat Reconnaissance Vehicle and an Abrams Main Battle Tank at Mount Bundey in the Northern Territory of Australia on the 15th of May 2017
 
 
The Boxer armoured truck,which shall already be a dozen years old by the time it enters British service,uniquely combines a modular hull which increases it's size,weight and cost for negligible benefit with a profile larger than a Main Battle Tank,ground pressure four times higher than an equivalent tracked vehicle,mechanicals which are exposed to enemy fire,a machine gun armed remote weapon station and protection against cannon fire both of which are inadequate in the front line and unnecessary anywhere else,and an ability to drive across Europe which,as the war in Ukraine has demonstrated,is utterly irrelevant.
 

Monday, 4 April 2022

The War In Ukraine: Starstruck

  
Air Defence Troop from 30 Commando Royal Marines with Starstreak at the Marine Air Ground Combat Training Centre at Twentynine Palms in California on the 15th of October 2021
 
 
Over twenty years after entering service with the British Army,the elderly Starstreak missile has been fired in anger for the first time,by the Ukrainian armed forces,apparently accounting for a Russian Mil Mi-28 Havoc attack helicopter,but within An Independent Army For An Independent Nation the proposed replacement for both the Starstreak and Javelin missiles is the Short Range Multirole Missile,a man portable weapon system (held in a platoon at battalion level,with one section of two systems per company),which is designed to engage both aircraft and armoured vehicles out to a range of five miles.
 

Sunday, 27 March 2022

The War In Ukraine: The Charlatans

 
A Challenger 2 Life Extension Project prototype
 
 
Ukrainian infantry ambush Russian medium tanks in confined spaces,where they are unable to compensate for their lack of situational awareness by operating en masse,which is one of the reasons why the heavy cavalry regiments of An Independent Army For An Independent Nation have close reconnaissance troops with Charlatan Cavalry Heavy Armoured Vehicles whose dummy turrets allow them to carry a greater weight of armour,sensors and countermeasures than standard Chargers,despite looking similar,making them particularly suited to finding targets for Four Inch Mortars and Chastisers (upgraded Challenger 2 Main Battle Tanks could be adapted to perform a similar role,were the Ajax fiasco to be cancelled).
 

Friday, 25 March 2022

The War In Ukraine: The Eye Of The Beholder

 
The General Staff of the Armed Forces of Ukraines estimate of Russian combat losses from the 24th of February to the 25th of March 2022

 
During the current unpleasantness the Ukrainian armed forces claim to have killed sixteen thousand and one hundred Russian soldiers and to have destroyed sixteen hundred and twenty-five Russian light Armoured Personnel Vehicles and five hundred and sixty-one Russian medium tanks,to a transformationalist this means that heavy Main Battle Tanks are obsolete and that infantry and light Armoured Personnel Vehicles are the future.
 

Friday, 11 March 2022

The War In Ukraine: The Rake's Progress

 
Russian Ground Forces Ural 432019 trucks marked with the V symbol being attacked by Ukrainian troops near Kiev during the Russian invasion of Ukraine on the 8th of March 2022
 
 
The progress of Vlad the Invader's attack on Ukraine is unclear at present,but it is worth remembering that eight decades ago it took the Wehrmacht six weeks to invade France,a nation of similar size,but there is one thing which is clear,had the proposed An Independent Army For An Independent Nation (a force which the British Army had the time,money and manpower to create) been deployed to Ukraine then Russian forces would have been soundly defeated by now,had they not been deterred from invading in the first place.
 

Tuesday, 8 March 2022

The War In Ukraine: Journalistic Licence

 
The British Broadcasting Corporation World News logo
 
 
Viewers of the British Broadcasting Corporation,Channel 4 and Sky might be forgiven for thinking that the streets of England and Wales are littered with the corpses of women and black people murdered by white policemen,meanwhile,back in the real world,seven out of ten murder victims are men and for every black person murdered by a white person there are three white people murdered by black people,racist and misandrist journalists now routinely use deceit by omission to create a distorted perception of reality in order to attack the objects of their hatred,consequently it is impossible to believe anything they say about the current war in Ukraine (or anything else).
  

Wednesday, 16 February 2022

An Independent Army For An Independent Nation: Ukraine,The Sixteenth of February,Twenty Twenty-one

  
A portrait of Boris Johnson the Member of Parliament for Uxbridge and South Ruislip
 
  
At this very moment,the United Kingdom's Prime Minister may be wondering why the British Army is unable to deploy a credible fighting formation to Eastern Europe,despite consuming the bulk of the defence budget,indeed,it is difficult to think of any conflict for which it was ever well prepared,herein we shall consider the options which would have been available with An Independent Army For An Independent Nation,a proposed force which does not exist at present but which could have been created within the current defence budget.
  
Field Marshal Montgomery with the goldfish on the 30th of October 1944
 
 
As expansion and contraction are normal states for an armed force,An Independent Army For An Independent Nation is designed to expand and contract and has changed only in scale over three decades,in stark contrast,the British Army suffers frequent radical disorganisations which reflect not changes in the enemy,the battlefield or technology but rather the prejudices of which ever senior officer is in post at the time,an indication that the army has the institutional memory of a goldfish.
  
7th Armoured Brigade commander Brigadier Patrick Cordingleys Challenger tank Call sign D14
 
 
An Independent Army For An Independent Nation shall be divided in to four ordinals (for want of a better word) only the first of which shall be available at short notice and this shall consist of the youngest soldiers and the newest equipment,soldiers recently retired from the First Ordinal shall join the Second Ordinal where they shall be issued with equipment also recently retired from the First Ordinal and therefore shall be serving with men and equipment they are familiar with,equipment which would otherwise be sold off for a fraction of it's replacement cost,for every soldier joining the Second Ordinal another shall be displaced from the Second Ordinal to the Third Ordinal and so on until discharge.
 
Officers of the 19th Regiment the survivors of Alma and Inkermann with their regimental colours and cannonball trophies
 
  
All soldiers shall be members of administrative regiments which in turn shall be part of administrative corps (the Intelligence Corps,the Royal Flying Corps,the Command Corps et ceteri),members of regular or Fencible regiments in the First Ordinal shall serve full time but members of Militia,Yeomanry and Volunteer regiments,who shall make up about a quarter of the total force,shall only serve part time,in the Second,Third and Fourth Ordinals all soldiers shall be mustered only once a year for roll call,pay,training,testing,inspection and parade,unless mobilised by Queen's Order,a process which shall take six,nine or twelve months respectively.
 
The Fourth Army Headquarters in a camouflaged train at Montigny Farm near Peronne in France on the 17th of October 1918
  
  
There shall be three operational field army headquarters in the First Ordinal,each commanded by a full general,such that under the proposed readiness cycle one may at all times be deployed or ready to deploy whilst a second commands domestic troops,subordinate to these armies being numbered field corps consisting of homogeneous role (infantry,light infantry,cavalry,artillery et ceteri) or mixed close combat,headquarters or train divisions each typically including a headquarters brigade,a train brigade and a number of role brigades which shall be in turn made up of battalions,each made up of companies,squadrons or batteries,each made up of platoons or troops,each of up to forty men drawn from various administrative regiments.
 
Megatron is a Challenger 2 Main Battle Tank at Theatre Entry Standard seen fitted with a Mobile Camouflage System
  
 
Under the terms of An Independent Army For An Independent Nation's proposed readiness cycle one third of the deployable regular First Ordinal force may be continuously deployed or ready to deploy,this shall typically include a small corps consisting of a composite division of corps and army troops and a mixed close combat division with a headquarters brigade,a train brigade,a cavalry brigade,a light infantry brigade and a medium infantry brigade and for a limited time this force may be doubled in size,with ninety days notice,by using part time soldiers to take over the regular's domestic standby tasks,the remaining third of the deployable force shall also be available at longer notice if need be.
  
MTLBVMK T72B3 2S3 Akatsiya and 2B16 Nona K of 138th Guards Motorized Rifle Brigade in Leningrad Oblast on the 2nd of March 2021
  
  
Thus,depending of how soon or how late the Prime Minister chooses to act the First Ordinal of An Independent Army For An Independent Nation shall be able to deploy an army of one small composite corps with a single close combat division which may be sustained there indefinitely or,for a limited period,an army of several corps with several close combat divisions,in each case with equipment which out classes anything in Russian service,such as the Charger and Matilda vehicles,and with the full spectrum of corps and army troops including Royal Flying Corps squadrons (and which may be supplemented by Royal Naval Air Service air wings and Royal Marines),given sufficient notice this latter force may be doubled,tripled or even quadrupled,albeit at a lower quality,by calling up one or more of the other ordinals,the possibility of such a large British army rampaging through the Donbas shall send a strong political message to the Kremlin.
  
Challenger 2 tanks in the desert colours of 2 Royal Tank Regiment are loaded onto flatbed rail trucks at Hohne Germany
 
  
Whatever the force size may be,all elements of it shall be able to deploy to Ukraine directly by air using the Centaurus aircraft,the small fleet of which shall be able to air drop the ready brigade of the Light Infantry Division in a single lift,via the Channel Tunnel using railways or by sea via Poland using the proposed Agincourt class landing ships,a number of which shall be routinely loaded with the equipment and supplies of a brigade (although pertinent only in the case of a short notice operation,the Light Infantry formations may be more rapidly deployed than Medium Infantry or Heavy Cavalry formations but,like formations equipped with the Ajax and Boxer vehicles,they shall be unsuitable for tactically offensive operations against Russian armoured and infantry forces due to their limited protection and fire power).
  
Crusader tanks on the assembly floor at a tank factory somewhere in England in 1941
  
  
The United Kingdom's most important military asset is it's civilian economy which generates the resources needed to fight a war,it is the defence industry which converts those resources in to the machines which win the war,the army is just the people who operate those machines,the last link in the kill chain (and historically the least successful,most expensive and least profitable link),An Independent Army For An Independent Nation therefore prioritises the nation's economy and defence industries over the whims of senior army officers.
  
The new Ajax prototype shown near its future assembly site in Merthyr Tydfil Wales on the 4th of March 2016
 
 
Since the abolition of the ancient post of Master-General of the Ordnance,which existed for hundreds of years for good reason,the British Army has squandered thousands of millions of pounds on the Ajax fiasco,which is hardly surprising as army officers are just civilians who have been on a short training course and history suggests they know little about warfare and even less about design and manufacture,but by creating a Secretary of State for Ordnance (advised by a Board of Ordnance led by a Master-General of the Ordnance and made up of professional Ordnance Corps officers expert in all matters relating to design,manufacture,storage,construction,maintenance,purchase and contracting),as a cabinet level position alongside the First Lord of the Admiralty and the Secretary of State for War,representing an Ordnance Office independent of the Admiralty Office and War Office,to oversee Royal Ordnance Factories,Royal Ordnance Depots and other facilities,army officers shall be confined to meddling in things which they might know a little about,whatever those may be.
 
The filled shell store at the National Shell Filling Factory at Chilwell in Nottinghamshire on the 15th of May 1917
  
 
The Royal Ordnance Factories and also the Royal Dockyards,which shall manufacture ordnance,equipment and supplies (such as the Quarter Inch Rifle,the Three Inch Mortar,the Four Inch Mortar,the Six Inch Rocket,the Five And A Half Inch Gun Howitzer,the Ballistic Artillery Rocket,the Ox,the Mule,the Pony,the Horse and the Elephant),shall be able to double production by temporarily working single set double shifts while a second set is recruited and trained,a process facilitated by increased numbers permitting greater specialisation,a nation which has the capacity to supply it's own armed forces shall also be better able to provide help to others.
 
An aerial view of British Army vehicles and materiel massed for the liberation of Kuwait
 
  
Thus,at the start of the recent crisis,in November,An Independent Army For An Independent Nation shall have provided the Prime Minister with the option of deploying a small but well equipped army of tens of thousands of men at short notice and of sustaining it continuously,now,several months later the Prime Minister would have the option of doubling the size of that force and sustaining that for many months,in future there would be the possibility of deploying the remaining third of the deployable First Ordinal force or of mobilising the remaining three ordinals to deploy a force of hundreds of thousands of men,in addition to supplying Ukraine with British made weapons,equipment and supplies,all without the need to seek the consent of foreign governments and with all of the money spent being fed straight back in to the United Kingdom's economy.